Chapter 4
Repeatable & Reproducible Results
Previous: One- Versus Two-Way Implications
When we do arithmetic, we follow rules. If each of us does not make a
mistake, we will get the same result as each other. Each calculation is
reproducible. Other people know how it was done. They can repeat it, and see if
they agree with our results. When we get a result by following rules or
instructions, other people can check our results. All they have to do is follow
the same rules.
Just as we have methods for doing arithmetic carefully and precisely, we also
have suggested methods for thinking carefully about what to accept, to do or to
decide. The ability to read and understand rules or suggestions precisely is
needed not only in persuading ourselves or others but also in following recipes,
instructions and rule-based reason.
The suggestions or rules which give repeatable and reproducible results are
the most certain and possibly the most correct. Reliable rule-based processes
give repeatable and reproducible results. These results do not depend on who
gets them. For instance, a good recipe can be followed by any cook - provided
the cook can find all the ingredients. Results should depend on the recipe, but
be independent of the cook.
Chapter Subsections: [ 4. First Puzzle ] [ 4. Second Puzzle ] [ 4. IF versus IFF ] [ 4. Joking About Logic ] [ 4. Imply or Suggest ] [ 4. One vs Two-Way Committents ] [ 4. Repeat- & Reproduc-ible? ] [ 4. Rules Limits & Benefits ] [ 4. Accidental Rules ] [ 4. Steps for Better Reason ]
Next: Limits and Benefits
|