Stick Diagram Solutions: Third Example
(brought to you by the number a, unknown on both sides
with whole number coefficients)
see animated solution for
3a+ 2 = 5a+4 (slightly different from text problem)
Now in the equation 5a + 16 = 3a+ 24 we imagine that a represents an unknown
length. In the stick below, the top stick has length 5a+16 while the bottom stick
has length 3a+24. The equation say both sticks have the same length, here 32.
Cutting off or subtracting 16 from both sticks (adding -16) gives
a stick of length 5a on top and a stick of length 3a+ 8 on bottom. This
second stick diagram represents the equation 5a = 3a + 8
Cutting off or subtracting 3a from both sticks (adding -3a) gives
But 2a = a + a. So half of the length of 2a = 8 is a. Therefore the
stick diagrams
and
imply a = 4.
But 3a = a + a + a. One third of the length of 3a is a. To find a, we will take cut
each stick into two equal pieces.
A Solution Table for 5a + 16 = 3a+ 24 follows.
If I was solving 5a + 16 = 3a+ 24
before a class, I would just
fill in the table and skip the work before it. Each table consists of a
diagram in the left column, a description of what is done or given in the
middle column, and the equivalent equations in the rightmost column. At
the moment, you are required to draw the stick diagram in the solution of the
equation. That is a crutch. Later on, only the equation column is
required with a few words to explain the operations.
Remember what we do one stick in a pair, we must do do the
other, to keep the lengths after the operation, the same. If two stick have
the same length, we cut 5 from and 8 from the other, the resulting pair of
sticks will not the same the length.
|
Solution Table for 5a+16 = 3a+ 24 |
| Stick Diagram |
Operation |
Equation |
|
|
Initial Equation
Given |
5a+16= 3a + 24 |
|
|
Subtract 16
(a.k.a add -16) |
5a = 3a + 8 |
|
|
Subtract 3a
(a.k.a add -3a) |
2a = 8 |
|
|
Take
|
a = 4 |
Check: Does a = 4 satisfy 5a+16 = 3a + 24
|
Left Hand Side |
=5a+16
=5(4)+16
=20 +16
= 36 |
Right Hand Side |
= 3a+ 24
=3(4)+24
=12+24
=36 |
Note: We can always check whether a number is a solution of an
equation or not by computing the left and right sides of an equation for or at
that number. If the two sides differ, the number is not a solution.
- If you are asked to show that a number satisfies an equation you do the
check.
- If you are asked to find a solution to an equation algebraically you
should show some work (besides trial and error) that leads to the solution.
Then you should check the solution.
Solutions of equations can always be checked. So before you hand-in an
answer, you can always check whether it is correct or not. And if it is not
correct, you should say so if you do not have time to find the correct
answer. Instructors want to see how you obtain the solution. If your
arithmetic without a calculator is usually good, the odd error in your work is
not as important as you showing that you have master an algebraic method for
solving problems.
Animated Example: 3a +4 = 5a+2